The Zeitgeist List · Coordinators · Never a head coach

Robb Smith.

Defensive coordinator · 9 seasons · 6 stints · 4 programs1 season ranked in the national top 10%
Own effect on the unit
Defense−0.27not distinguishable from zero
model fit as of 2026-09-04

The tenure clock

Every stop re-aligned to its own first year, so the stops stack instead of scrolling past each other. The gray dashed line is a reference, not a path: each point is the median of whoever was still in the job that year, across every real OC/DC stint since 2014 at that role, and the pool shrinks year over year because surviving to a later year means not having been fired.

100th — best in the country90th — elite — top 10%75th — top quarter50th — national median25th — bottom quarter0 — worst in the countryHis defense’s national rank, by year of tenureYear 1Year 2Year 3Year of that tenure, not calendar yearn=730n=430n=235Arkansas, year 1: 92nd percentileArkansas, year 2: 19th percentileArkansas, year 3: 25th percentileArkansasMinnesota, year 1: 29th percentileMinnesota, year 2: 41st percentileMinnesotaRutgers, year 1: 26th percentileRutgers, year 2: 23rd percentileRutgersDuke, year 1: 55th percentileDukeRutgers, year 1: 1st percentileRutgersmedian still in the job
Arkansas 2014–2016
Minnesota 2017–2018
Rutgers 2020–2021
Duke 2022–2022
Rutgers 2025–2025
Median of those still in the job, that year of a tenure. A shrinking pool, not a path.
Arkansas, 3 years
▼ 67.2
91.8 to 24.6 percentile.
Minnesota, 2 years
▲ 12.3
28.8 to 41.2 percentile.
Rutgers, 2 years
▼ 3.7
26.4 to 22.7 percentile.
Median defensive coordinator
+0.5
first season to last, across 235 stints of 3+ years. 50.6% improve at all.

Every stop on the calendar

YearsProgramWalked intoYear 1BestVs. talent
2014–2016Arkansas14.091.891.8▼ 36.7
2017–2017Minnesota80.928.828.8▼ 21.9
2018–2018Minnesota28.841.241.2▼ 12.4
2020–2021Rutgers13.526.426.4▼ 25.9
2022–2022Duke0.455.355.3▲ 4.5
2025–2025Rutgers8.61.11.1▼ 51.8

Minnesota 2017–2017: ranked 81st the year before he arrived, 29th at its best — went backwards.

Rutgers 2025–2025: ranked 9th the year before he arrived, 1st at its best — went backwards.

← Back to the Coordinators’ Climb